Alexia Anders and her boyfriend Jay Romero are sitting in her bedroom, holding hands while having a wholesome conversation about a recent church sermon. Jay is also her youth pastor, and is pleased with Alexia's... interest in the topic. They are interrupted when Alexia's parents, London Rose and Rusty Nails, appear at the doorway to let Alexia know that they're leaving for an errand. The parents decide that it's okay to leave Alexia and Jay alone together, since they're both good Christians and are sure to behave responsibly.
Now alone, Alexia and Jay talk about the fact they haven't had sex yet. They wonder if they should, and worry that it might be wrong or that the church will judge them. After discussing their turmoil over the topic some more, they agree that they don't need to rush: they should start slowly, and just kiss. They begin with sweet, innocent kisses, but find themselves wanting more. They make an excuse to go further, and experiment with more kissing, and over-the-clothes groping.
Alexia and Jay then experiment with under-the-clothes fondling, which ignites their hunger for sexual acts even further. Jay pulls down Alexia's panties and tries cunnilingus, and then they try 69ing on the bed. Desperate for more, they decide to try a little missionary sex, convincing themselves that it should be okay as long as they're using a condom. However, after trying that for a bit, Jay admits he didn't enjoy that as much. They wonder if the condom is to blame, so they remove the condom and try missionary again, then progress to sideways spooning sex with lots of body-grabbing, desperate to keep fucking... all the way to a vaginal creampie.
